Pular para o conteúdo principal

Questão de Inglês — Interpretação de texto | Reading comprehension — CESPE / CEBRASPE 2023

InglêsInterpretação de texto | Reading comprehension
Código
ce161597
Banca
CESPE / CEBRASPE
Órgão
SME do Recife - PE
Ano
2023
Nível
Superior
Cargo
Professor II - Disciplina: Língua Inglesa
Text 7A1

     Artificial intelligence still has difficulties processing requests in one language, without the additional complications of translation. Michael Housman, chief data science officer at RapportBoost.AI, explained that the ideal scenario for machine learning and artificial intelligence is something with fixed rules and a clear-cut measure of success or failure. He named chess as an obvious example. This happened faster than anyone anticipated because of the game’s very clear rules and limited set of moves. Housman elaborated, “Language is almost the opposite of that. There aren’t as clearly-cut and defined rules.”
      I asked Dr. Jorge Majfud, Associate Professor of Spanish, at Jacksonville University, to explain why consistently accurate language translation has thus far eluded AI. He replied, “The problem is that considering the ‘entire’ sentence is still not enough.” He noted that sarcasm and irony only make sense within this widened context. Similarly, idioms can be problematic for automated translations.
       Dr. Majfud warned, “We should be aware of the fragility of their ‘interpretation.’ Because to translate is basically to interpret, not just an idea but a feeling. Human feelings and ideas that only humans can understand — and sometimes not even we, humans, understand other humans.” He noted that cultures, gender, and even age can pose barriers to this understanding and also contended that an over-reliance on technology is leading to our cultural and political decline. Dr. Majfud mentioned that Argentinean writer Julio Cortázar used to refer to dictionaries as “cemeteries”. He suggested that automatic translators could be called “zombies”.

David Pring-Mill. Why Hasn’t AI Mastered Language Translation? Internet:<singularityhub.com>  (adapted).
Based on text 7A1, judge the following item.Despite the advances in technology, translation is still a difficult task for artificial intelligence.
  1. CCerto
  2. EErrado
Revelar gabarito e comentário

GabaritoC — Certo

Comentário gerado por IA. É um apoio ao estudo, ancorado em fontes, mas pode conter imprecisões — confira sempre na fonte oficial (lei, súmula, edital e gabarito da banca). Encontrou um erro? Use “Reportar”.

Text comprehension — Translation difficulties

Gabarito: ✅ CERTO. The text clearly supports the statement that translation is still a difficult task for artificial intelligence, despite technological advances. The author cites experts who highlight the inherent challenges.

Michael Housman explains that language lacks the fixed rules and clear-cut measures of success found in games like chess:

"Language is almost the opposite of that. There aren’t as clearly-cut and defined rules."

Dr. Jorge Majfud adds that considering the entire sentence is still insufficient, and that sarcasm, irony, idioms, and cultural nuances complicate translation:

"The problem is that considering the ‘entire’ sentence is still not enough."

He also emphasizes that translation is essentially interpretation of feelings and ideas, which only humans can fully grasp:

"to translate is basically to interpret, not just an idea but a feeling."

Therefore, the text unequivocally confirms that AI has not mastered translation, making the item correct.

✅ CERTO.

Link permanente: /questoes/ce161597