Pular para o conteúdo principal

Questão de Inglês — Ensino da Língua Estrangeira Inglesa — CESPE / CEBRASPE 2026

InglêsEnsino da Língua Estrangeira Inglesa
Código
ce227360
Banca
CESPE / CEBRASPE
Órgão
SEDUC-SE
Ano
2026
Nível
Superior
Cargo
Professor de Educação Básica - Área de Atuação: Grupo I - Ensino Fundamental e Médio - Disciplina: Língua Inglesa
Text 11A2-II

        The production of the BNCC (Base Nacional Comum Curricular) gave rise to a series of discussions on the role of school systems in Brazil. A number of educators and researchers expressed their concerns about the homogenizing perspective reflected and refracted by the document. In other words, in a country as socially and culturally diverse as Brazil is, how might an educational instrument outline “essential types of knowledge” for students, irrespective of their personal, regional, and local specificities?

        On the other hand, the document also incorporates a discourse which values peripheral contributions. In doing so, it adopts a more overtly progressive tone, which accentuates the importance of diversity. Szundy, in her examination of the BNCC’s English Language component, underscores how the document subscribes to the notion of ideological literacy. The author believes that the BNCC’s introduction of an intercultural axis brings the document closer to an ideological stance which “understands languages as resources that put us in contact with otherness, with plural and equally valid ways of being and of being in the world.” A bit further, the author argues that “BNCC may urge us to situate teaching within the realm of decolonial practices”.

        We could be led to think that BNCC, by laying emphasis on the situated nature of learners’ knowledge, reinforces democratic ideals and seeks to promote unrestricted access to critical education. This interpretation, albeit problematic, seems less harmful than the enunciation of universal, “essential knowledge.” However, it is also Szundy who, in her analysis of the competences and skills associated with the teaching of English in the Brazilian 6th grade, encounters an autonomous view of reading: “The use of verbs such as formulate, identify and locate in these three reading skills is at odds with the formative and political understanding of the English language found in the component’s introduction, as well as with the document’s overall apprehension of the lingua franca concept (…)”.

        BNCC’s discursive and ideological diversity refracts a myriad of epistemological and axiological contradictions, illuminating a clash between ideological systems. Amidst such conflicts, however, we may find openings for the creation of new curricula. This point is repeatedly made in Szundy’s analysis as she dwells on the skills and competences outlined by the BNCC for the 9th grade in Middle Education. In such descriptors, the use of verbs such as debate, analyse and discuss could suggest the development of more critical and political linguistic practices. Yet, in Szundy’s own words: “In BNCC, the English language’s status as a lingua franca (…) is designed to assist students in developing the skills and competences they need to become selfentrepreneurs and to participate in the global world without ever calling its macro and micro structures into question; without ever examining how these very structures operate to keep huge swaths of the population at bay, deprived of any access to the commodities of an utopian global village.”

        BNCC, a normative document, prescribes a conditioning of students’ reading practices. The underlying pedagogical conception assumes the existence of a Cartesian reader, equipped with enough autonomy to identify the precise routes laid down by authors, as if fruition automatically conferred such abilities. This project is incongruous with the nature of language itself, i.e., with the fact that meaning emerges through socially and historically situated contact with otherness (even when that otherness is materialized in texts). Here, the notion of ideological sign comes in handy once more, since meanings only arise in concrete communicative situations, where they are imbued with existing social values.

Internet:  <doi.org> (adapted).
According to text 11A2-II, the key contradiction Szundy finds in the BNCC’s English language component, particularly in 6th grade skills, is
  1. Athe existence of an autonomous view of reading, that can be attested by the use of verbs like identify and locate, which clashes with the document’s formative nature.
  2. Bthe use of critical verbs like debate in the component’s introduction that are missing in the actual skill descriptors.
  3. Cthe existence of a strong emphasis on the learner that antagonizes democratic views of education.
  4. Dthe focus of digital literacy over traditional print-based reading skills.
  5. Ethe failure to incorporate an intercultural axis into the curriculum.
Revelar gabarito e comentário

GabaritoA — the existence of an autonomous view of reading, that can be attested by the use of verbs like identify and locate, which clashes with the document’s formative nature.

Comentário gerado por IA. É um apoio ao estudo, ancorado em fontes, mas pode conter imprecisões — confira sempre na fonte oficial (lei, súmula, edital e gabarito da banca). Encontrou um erro? Use “Reportar”.

Contradição na BNCC – Análise de Szundy

Gabarito: letra A. Szundy aponta que, nas habilidades de 6º ano do componente de Língua Inglesa da BNCC, há uma autonomous view of reading (visão autônoma de leitura), evidente pelo uso de verbos como identify e locate, que entra em conflito com a natureza formativa e política do documento.

O texto afirma:

“However, it is also Szundy who, in her analysis of the competences and skills associated with the teaching of English in the Brazilian 6th grade, encounters an autonomous view of reading: ‘The use of verbs such as formulate, identify and locate in these three reading skills is at odds with the formative and political understanding of the English language found in the component’s introduction, as well as with the document’s overall apprehension of the lingua franca concept (…)’.”

Portanto, a contradição central está na oposição entre a autonomous view (verbos de localização/identificação) e a abordagem formativa/ideológica defendida na introdução.

Alternativa A — ✅ Correta ⟵ GABARITO

Exatamente o que o texto descreve: uma visão autônoma de leitura atestada por verbos como identify e locate, confrontando o caráter formativo do documento.

Alternativa B — ❌ Incorreta

O texto menciona verbos como debate, analyse, discuss nas habilidades de 9º ano, não na introdução. Não há afirmação de que esses verbos estão ausentes nos descritores do 6º ano; a contradição é entre a visão autônoma do 6º ano e a introdução formativa.

Alternativa C — ❌ Incorreta

A ênfase no aprendiz é discutida, mas não como contradição. O texto não afirma que ela antagoniza visões democráticas de educação.

Alternativa D — ❌ Incorreta

Não há menção a digital literacy ou habilidades de leitura impressa tradicional nesta parte da análise.

Alternativa E — ❌ Incorreta

O texto afirma que a BNCC introduz um eixo intercultural (intercultural axis), aproximando-se de uma postura ideológica. Portanto, não há falha em incorporá-lo.

Gabarito: letra A.

Link permanente: /questoes/ce227360